No wonder we feel sick viewing so much bleeding

“If it bleeds, it leads” is an axiom that journalists follow in selecting news for display on page one of a newspaper and to lead broadcast PAPER BUNDLEnews shows. We know this practice sells newspapers and increases broadcast viewership. Unfortunately, watching this stuff can make you sick.

No wonder that we feel yukkie after watching and re-watching videos of bombings, beheadings, shootings, beatings, etc., especially when we watch and watch and watch the same scene again and again. You don’t have to be a psychologist to guess at the results.

In a national survey of 2,500 Americans, one in four admitted to feeling a great deal of stress in the previous month and blamed news as one of the reasons for the stress. It’s like a scab on your arm. You pick at it until it bleeds.

Doctors Mehmet Oz and Michael Roizen reported this and other survey results and suggested how to combat this maladay in their mid-June newspaper column. Their two leading suggestions:

First, Watch it once. Then turn it off.

Second, Better yet, get your news the old-fashioned way by reading a newspaper.

We know that we’re drawn to bad news. We tend to share what went wrong at the office with a spouse at the end of a work day. We describe how our vacations were marred by unexpected events. We talk of war before we consider peace. We criticize bad behavior rather than concentrate on the good.

So, why wouldn’t we expect to sell newspapers and broadcast time by following the “when it bleeds, it leads” practice?

My wife and I became so fed up with television news that we nearly suffered heart attacks before finding a remedy:

First problem: One minute of news followed by one to two minutes of advertising, some of it tasteless, much of it sexually demeaning, most of it repetitious.

Second problem: Editorializing the news. Example: Igorning what was once known as free press-fair trial guidelines by acting as judge and jury of someone, often a celebrity, being accused of a crime. Doesn’t anyone read and understand the importance of the Sixth Amendment these days?

Here’s how my wife and I solved the problem:

First, we read a newspaper daily, and we understand the difference between the news and editorial functions of media.

Second, we watch the evening PBS one-hour news show and C-SPAN television stations that cover proceedings of the federal government and other public affairs programming. As a result, we watched and heard the speeches announcing the candidacy of most presidential hopefuls, speeches by the president, committee proceedings, congressional voting and other events central to governance.

We do, however, make an exception to these rules by watching people suffer concussions, break limbs and bloody noses while the Oregon Ducks play football.

3 thoughts on “No wonder we feel sick viewing so much bleeding”

  1. Evocative column, Dean. One key point you make is that “we’re drawn to bad news.” That’s about our core survival instincts. But bad news isn’t all the news — as you note with your choices in television news. You might enjoy talking with two of our new faculty members. Nicole Dahmen works on “recovery journalism”: journalism that helps a community experiencing trauma move forward toward recovery. Kathryn Thier works on “solution journalism”: journalism focused on solving problems. I enjoy your good, thought-provoking writing, Dean. Thank you.

    Like

  2. Dean – I have to agree with your assessment of “news entertainment” these days. And furthermore, I get very VERY annoyed at the egregious errors in just about every on-line news report that I read: punctuation, grammar, spelling, word and phrase displacement and so on. And like you, I scan the news headlines online and skip anything that smacks of bleeding, terrorism, victimizing, sensationalism, celebrity foibles and indiscretions, and matter of scandalous dress and comportment. Which make online news reading very fast. The daily newspaper tells me more about my community. (Although access to breaking news on local TV channels does help to figure out where smoke is coming from when there is a fire in the area.) We watch PBS programs, documentaries, and frequently Rachel Maddow, whose methods of commentary are sometimes too suggestive rather than factual, but who does keep on top of political happenings up to the minute.

    As for stress, I recently read a report that cat videos are popular because they are great stress-relievers, which may explain some of the proliferation of them online. Or perhaps they are just entertaining. Laughing is good for us. Or perhaps people are better off just having a cat or dog around to provide that stress relief.

    At any rate, authentic journalism is damn near dead. We’ll watch Bill Moyers any time. Dan Rather still hangs in there. Not very many of them left, however. International news reporting isn’t much better.

    I’m beginning to think that burying our heads in the sand and getting a hobby and a cat will make us all better off!

    Regards, Lee Kirk (2 cats on board)

    Like

  3. August 29 was the 10 year Anniversary of Hurricane Katrina, and in the New Orleans area news and documentaries abounded beginning 2 weeks before the anniversary with the rehash of the terror we witnessed and the aftermath of suffering and neglect by everything in which we had faith.

    Yes, it was tough and anyone who was affected had altered goals and lost contentment, but we struggled through and more-or-less survived.

    Seeing bodies floating in the floodwaters or flooded and collapsed homes or people stranded on I-10 for 5 days without food or water over and over again on each new broadcast did not fix anything. It put everyone who talked to me about it an a depressed state.

    My husband and I decided to tune in to the news in time for the weather and then he read books and I painted after dinner while my 2 big dogs snuggled at my feet or switched next to hubs on the sofa. This was a good solution for us.

    Thanks for bringing this up! We can relate to everything you said.

    Kathleen

    Like

Leave a comment